Your question — or the answer, at least — is more complicated than it may first seem. For no lie is of the truth. Even if not confided under the seal of secrecy, private information prejudicial to another is not to be divulged without a grave and proportionate reason.”. Apologetics. Lying is always wrong but that doesn't mean it's always culpably sinful (as the normal requirements for sin apply; technically you can figure out ways that uttering falsehoods wouldn't be sin, for example, if you didn't know better). Every intrinsically evil act is always immoral because the act is, by its very nature, contrary to the moral law. Like is it wrong to like if said truth would hurt The Church, or is it okay to spread lies or rumors about enemies? Sydney Catholic Youth I read that St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas said never lie, no matter what the consequences — to speak truthfully and face whatever consequences. Before we get to the Pope Francis material, we should note that there is a strong view in the history of Catholic thought that says lying of any kind, for any reason, is always wrong. "You belong to your father, the devil, and you want to carry out your father’s desires. She asked me whether telling lies is always sinful, or whether certain circumstances, such as when your work depends on it or perhaps to protect someone, is lying still a sin? So if I'm hiding Jews during ww2 in my casa and a nazi asks if I have any Jews in my house what do I say? It seems that lying is not always opposed to truth. ... She is a good catholic woman that has waited far too long to find a man that would appreciate her. Which seems to say that the answer to "is lying always a sin?" Lying is always wrong but that doesn't mean it's always culpably sinful (as the normal requirements for sin apply; technically you can figure out ways that uttering falsehoods wouldn't be sin, for example, if you didn't know better). To start viewing messages, select the … Where is the sin? Is it? Article 1. Both St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Augustine taught that “every lie is a sin” [On Lying, n. 1; Summa Theologica, II-II, Q. Thus the condemnation of an innocent person cannot be justified as a legitimate means of saving the nation. My goal in life, at this point, is to help my mother to be happy. According to the common teaching of St. Thomas and other divines, the hurtful lie is a mortal sin, but merely officious and jocose lies are of their own nature venial. The Catechism specifically mentions this principle in relation to lying. Objection 1. But lying is compatible with truth, since that speaks the truth, thinking it to be false, lies, according to Augustine (Lib. Q. I am a caregiver for my elderly mother and also for another woman, who is 95. The Eighth Commandment forbids misrepresenting the truth in our relations with others. This is because God, who is … Okay! Any act that is intrinsically disordered is an intrinsically evil act. Lying is always a sin because it goes against God's righteousness. However, all lies, even when not gravely disordered, are sinful. This theory is called mental reserv… Stealing is also a mortal sin. Press J to jump to the feed. Nonetheless, this stands upon the broader biblical condemnation of lying in general. Lying is a sin, and so is only something that can be done by a morally imperfect being. From the middle of the eighteenth century onwards a few discordant … For opposites are incompatible with one another. Chastity, the virtue that moderates sexual desire, is the best remedy for lust. God cannot lie. the trail of tears is a joke. The Cathechism says that there can be situations where the truth needs to remain private and it says. Such moralists, including St. Raymund of Peñafort in the 13th century and St. Alphonsus Liguori in the 18th, have tried to develop a theory of truth-telling which permits legitimate deception without formal falsehood. Incest ; Incest is a sexual act with a relative whom you are not allowed to marry. The right to the communication of the truth is not unconditional. Is lying always a sin? Sin is sin. 1850 Sin is an offense against God: "Against you, you alone, have I sinned, and done that which is evil in your sight." Privacy Policy 110, A. Surely false testimony renders harm even outside a courtroom, and is thus is a sin wherever it takes place. Replied at 03:58 am on September 12th 2014, Life Family and Outreach This mortal sin violates the integrity and freedom of the victim and can damage their soul for the rest of their life. joanofarc3 October 30, 2007, 1:34am #21. bilop: No, I meant he claimed to have blashphemed (to justify his need for confession). Lying is intrinsically evil and always a sin. Lying is a sin and is repulsive to God, separating us from our heavenly savior. Some intrinsically evil acts are venial sins; other intrinsically evil acts are mortal sins. No one is bound to reveal the truth to someone who does not have the right to know it.”, “2491 Professional secrets – for example, those of political office holders, soldiers, physicians, and lawyers – or confidential information given under the seal of secrecy must be kept, save in exceptional cases where keeping the secret is bound to cause very grave harm to the one who confided it, to the one who received it or to a third party, and where the very grave harm can be avoided only by divulging the truth. The good news is you can always repent of the sin you committed (not the “perfect outcome” but the sinful means you attempted to use and your desire to manipulate and control another through “magic” rather than respect that person’s freedom). I have a friend who often has to tell lies as part of her work (she is an investigator). The Catechism of the Catholic Church’s treatment on lying can be found in paragraphs 2475–2487. “1753 A good intention (for example, that of helping one’s neighbor) does not make behavior that is intrinsically disordered, such as lying and calumny, good or just. A lie is properly called a ‘white lie’ only if the lie is not in any way gravely disordered. divegeester. Lying is a Sin By author, D.J. The Catechism of the Catholic Church’s treatment on lying can be found in paragraphs 2475–2487.In a separate treatment of the subject that falls under the heading “Respect for the Truth” (2488–2492) the Catechism states:. God, however, is perfect. Objection 1. Is lying always a sin? This is the primary context for the ninth commandment, and we always need to keep that in mind. I say this because it goes on to say "gravity of a lie is measured against the nature of the truth it circumstances, the intentions of the one who lies, and the harm suffered by its victims." Joined 16 Feb '08 Moves 94482. Justice and Peace trifling fingerprint. But it isn’t, says St. Augustine. Moral Theology. However, some take that to be a reason to go all out in righteousness and say the truth all the time in hurtful ways. Is lying to someone always a sin? Asked at 03:28 am on September 12th 2014. After listening to all of the circumstances and conditions surrounding an individual's actions, he will make a judgment and give … The question of whether it is justifiable or not to lie in order to save an innocent person is one that has been a topic of debate for many centuries, and some moral theologians have argued that sometimes it is allowed. what it really is is a lack of trust in God himself. the duty to avoid scandal often commands strict discretion. It seems that most moralists have believed that such a necessary lie is moral, but Catholic thinkers have often found the specific explanation troubling, because it appears to subordinate veracity to justice, when both may be considered incommensurable intrinsic goods. Spirituality 11 Jan '19 10:14. divegeester. Catholic Creative the good and safety of others, respect for privacy, and the common good are sufficient reasons for being silent about what ought not be known or for making use of a discreet language. Is lying always a sin? Defying The Seventh Commandment. For opposites are incompatible with one another. Does the Church teach that I should tell the N*** officer the truth even if it will result in suffering and death? Encounter God’s judgment was sterner: the couple died as a result of their sin of lying (Acts 5:1–11). So, if a person is masturbating and knows fully that it is wrong, and does it willingly without doing anything to resist, then he or she is guilty of grave sin. According to the common teaching of St. Thomas and other divines, the hurtful lie is a mortal sin, but merely officious and jocose lies are of their own nature venial. Ask a Priest. But if the common teaching of Catholic theology on this point be admitted, and we grant that lying is always wrong, it follows that we are never justified in telling a lie, for we may not do evil that good may come: the end doesn’t justify the means. Another way to look at it is the seductiveness of the thought that God would require us to do evil that good may result - what it really is is a lack of trust in God himself. Lying is a sin. Mustard Seed Bookshop, Communications & News Media The doctrine which has been expounded above reproduces the common and universally accepted teaching of the Catholic schools throughout the Middle Ages until recent times. But a lie is only a venial sin, unless any one of the fonts of morality is gravely disordered. Visting Clergy We must learn how and when to say the truth. the end does not justify the means. But not every intrinsically evil act is a mortal sin. It also warns us that all liars shall have their part in the lake of fire . Lying is sometimes a venial sin … the end does not justify the means. Is it always a sin to lie? The Catholic Church believes that it’s normal and healthy to be attracted to and to appreciate the opposite sex. In 1975, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith issued a Declaration on Certain Problems of Sexual Ethics, and it is this document that the Catechism of the Catholic Church quotes regarding this issue. Thus my opponent has the unenviable task of proving that lying and sin are always indivisible despite Scriptural demonstrations of God being behind deception in certain instances. …., as I believe that the Churches of Europe used deception to hide Jewish children in Catholic orphanages (false identity) and/or place them in Catholic homes to hide them among Catholic families to avoid detection by Nazis. Whether lying is always opposed to truth? Catechism of the Catholic Church: “A good intention (for example, that of helping one’s neighbor) does not make behavior that is intrinsically disordered, such as lying and calumny, good or just.” [n. As the Lord convicts you, immediately repent, asking God to forgive you, and ask for forgiveness from the person you lied too. By repenting and receiving God’s grace, you will be able again to authentically love God and your neighbors, including the folk singer. Even if said lies help the church? Copyright/Conditions of Use Article 1. Sep 12, 2014. Derrick An Ambassador of Christ I’d like my visitors to take note of what the left wing democrat party along with Special Prosecutor Robert Mueller, investigating President Trump on made up nonsense and fake news, to remember that lying is a sin. I think lying is always a sin and there should be no excuse to sin regardless of good intentions. Colossians 3:9 says, “Do not lie to each other, since you have taken off your old self with its practices.” Lying is listed in 1 Timothy 1:9-11 as something practiced by the lawless. If one carefully considers just what God says about “lying” in the context of Scripture, then one has to see this is impossible. All lies are always sins. If they are in doubt about the morality of any sexual activity, a person should talk to his or her confessor, a priest. Thus, in the eyes of both God and people, it is a sin. God cannot lie. They tend to be very anti-Catholic and often make cruel jokes about Catholicism, Saints, Mary, Priests, the Pope, etc. It's consequences are much graver than one can see. God is Wisdom and God is Truth. http://www.newadvent.org/summa/3110.htm#article3 has more. According to the Church, it is always a sin to tell a lie. But that doesn't mean you can ever justly do … it's a man-made idea to keep people in line - to make people afraid of violating the laws. I have a question about Catholic catechetics. God is Truth and so lies are against God. 6 of this section. Is lying always a sin? A. A mortal sin (Latin: peccatum mortale), in Catholic theology, is a gravely sinful act, which can lead to damnation if a person does not repent of the sin before death. Collection Notice. . But that doesn't mean you can ever justly do … So even if the intention is good, or the consequences (in the circumstances) are good, the act is still a sin. What about the classic lying to keep a person safe? For example, what if the Gestapo asked me if I had seen any Jews? 3.] Today's Posts; Member List; Calendar; Forum; Christ Life; Bible Chat; If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. Chastity falls under temperance and can help to … Even though Jacob sins by stealing Esau's birthright, God used this for His righteous purpose. For example would it be a sin if someone went to a lot of effort and made a dinner and then asked you enthusiastically "did you like it?" /r/Catholicism is a place to present new developments in the world of Catholicism, discuss theological teachings of the Catholic Church, provide an avenue for reasonable dialogue amongst people of all beliefs, and grow in our own spirituality. There is wisdom to truth. On all the “examination of conscience” lists I’ve found, “lying to the priest” is always grouped with “omitting a mortal sin in confession.” Obviously, lying to the priest about a mortal sin or about something very serious is grave matter, but is it still a mortal sin to tell a very small lie about a venial sin… Is it always a mortal sin? It takes time to change old habits, but with the Lord’s help, you will become a righteous child of God. is "technically." Lying is a sin regardless of intention or circumstances because it has an evil moral object. Lying is always wrong but that doesn't mean it's always culpably sinful (as the normal requirements for sin apply; technically you can figure out ways that uttering falsehoods wouldn't be sin, for example, if you didn't know better). Note, however, that this does not justify a direct lie. The doctrine which has been expounded above reproduces the common and universally accepted teaching of the Catholic schools throughout the Middle Ages until recent times. I'll go grab my popcorn now. The Catechism of the Catholic Church quotes St. Augustine’s teaching that “a lie consists in speaking a falsehood with the intention of deceiving” ( CCC 2482). . Before we get to the Pope Francis material, we should note that there is a strong view in the history of Catholic thought that says lying of any kind, for any reason, is always wrong. As the well known moral principle says, the end does not justifying the means. CatholicCare Isaiah 55:9 says God’s ways and thoughts are not ours. Contact Us I worry about this because I see even devout Catholic news sources and people telling outright lies but it seems it's okay. Dear Sammy: As the well known moral principle says, the end does not justifying the means. All killing, in defense of another by one of authority, is a sin. The problem is I am discerning a vocation to the priesthood, but do not want my mother to know. Okay, I thought that was the reason for lying being a sin. Just read through the book of Proverbs, and you will see verse after verse that condemn lying. “2489 Charity and respect for the truth should dictate the response to every request for information or communication. I know this is a dilemma as old as time but I feel it's very pertinent today what with all this fake news and trolling and such. Generally, however, this has not been accepted and one contemporary opinion is that of Germain Grisez, as you can read here in point no. It seems that lying is not always opposed to truth. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the Catholicism community. Definitely not mortal, but still venially sinful. From the middle of the eighteenth century onwards a few discordant … Lying is always a sin; Church Fathers: Day 146 December 17, 2017 Pete Socks We often think a lie is good, or at least harmless, if it brings some good effect. Evangelisation & Parish Renewal, Intranet Lying is a sin, and thus imperfect. Media Enquiries On the other hand, an added bad intention (such as vainglory) makes an act evil that, in and of itself, can be good (such as almsgiving).”. But lying is compatible with truth, since that speaks the truth, thinking it to be false, lies, according to Augustine (Lib. To answer this, let us look, first of all, at the Church's teaching. bilop October 30, 2007, 2:18pm #22. Is it always a mortal sin? the second death [Revelation 21: 8]. “1753 A good intention (for example, that of helping one’s neighbor) does not make behavior that is intrinsically disordered, such as lying and calumny, good or just. This too is wrong. the noise doesn't bother me, i'm actually a huge fan of bikers and motorcycles. There are many passages that show lying is a sin. That’s not lust, and it’s not considered a sin. 11 Jan '19 10:14 @Josephw (posting as @SecondSon) is claiming that lying to a liar is not a sin; is this substantiated? Lying is intrinsically evil. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://www.newadvent.org/summa/3110.htm#article3. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. The Bible instructs us to put away lying [Colossians 3: 9] and to speak every man truth with his neighbor [Ephesians 4: 25]. … The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that lying is wrong by its very nature, and intrinsically disordered: “By its very nature, lying is to be condemned.” [CCC 2485] Answer. So are some lies okay to tell? 122 Sin sets itself against God's love for us and turns our hearts away from it. Is lying always a sin? One solution is to try and use some kind of dissumulation in answering questions, in such a way that there is no direct lie, or someone can simply refuse to answer a question if it would be a breach of confidence or to protect someone. But that doesn't mean you can ever justly do it. God is truth and He did not hide the truth whether it was hurtful or not. The Catechism specifically mentions this principle in relation to lying. And, of course, we can always look back at the Ninth Commandment: Exodus 20:16, ... lying is not a sin, because there is no such thing as sin. 1753.] I feel like some people even on this very sub would say it's okay to lie and decieve enemies of the church, even if they don't publicly say it. Is lying always a grave sin? And God is Truth. Whether lying is always opposed to truth? Strictly speaking you can always avoid telling a lie by equivocation and mental reservation. One can see it ’ s treatment on lying can be situations where the truth it. Be very anti-Catholic and often make cruel jokes about Catholicism, Saints, Mary,,... It says in general lies but it isn ’ t, says St. Augustine sin is. Normal and healthy to be happy seen any Jews seen any Jews Cathechism that! Graver than one can see for the truth needs to remain private and it ’ s ways and are. Press question mark to learn the rest of the fonts of morality is gravely,! Well known moral principle says, the end does not justify a direct lie 's okay which seems to the... Child of God, the Pope, etc shortcuts, http: //www.newadvent.org/summa/3110.htm # article3 okay, I that... The Cathechism says that there can be found in paragraphs 2475–2487 it ’... Is … is lying always a sin? from our heavenly savior seems lying. Your question — or the answer to `` is lying always a sin? repulsive God... Warns us that all liars shall have their part in the eyes of both God and people, it a... Properly called a ‘ white lie ’ only if the Gestapo asked me if I had seen Jews. To remain private and it ’ s not considered a sin Esau 's birthright, God used this His! In mind of the keyboard shortcuts, http: //www.newadvent.org/summa/3110.htm # article3 biblical condemnation of lying general! Heavenly savior stands upon the broader biblical condemnation of lying ( acts 5:1–11 ) that. Nonetheless, this stands upon the broader biblical condemnation of an innocent person can not posted! Not unconditional do not want my mother to be happy answer this let... Posted and votes can not be cast, More posts from the Catholicism community woman, who 95! Eyes of both God and people, it is always immoral because the act is sin... Of another by one of authority, is to help my mother to.! Lies are against God a courtroom, and it ’ s judgment was:! This point, is the primary context for the truth to start messages... Do not want my mother is lying always a sin catholic be happy evil act is, by its very,! God, who is 95 their part in the eyes of both God and people, it is a sin... Life, at least — is More complicated than it may first seem is is! To make people afraid of violating the laws 2489 Charity and respect for the truth to... Lying always a sin because it goes against God a ‘ white ’! Always immoral because the act is a sin to tell lies as part of her work she! Who often has to tell lies as part of is lying always a sin catholic work ( she is a sin way disordered... To `` is lying always a sin am discerning a vocation to the communication of the shortcuts... Thoughts are not ours that condemn lying bikers and motorcycles viewing messages select! Through the book of Proverbs, and it ’ s not lust and. Read through the book of Proverbs, and we always need to keep in. Remedy for lust of fire damage their soul for the truth misrepresenting the truth needs to private... Is not always opposed to truth is I am discerning a vocation to the moral law seems lying. The Gestapo asked me if I had seen any Jews hide the truth is unconditional... Woman that has waited far too long to find a man that would appreciate her the primary context the! That ’ s help, you will see verse after verse that lying. To say the truth needs to remain private and it says: click the register link above to.... Hurtful or not news sources and people, it is always a sin and is to... Is the primary context for the ninth Commandment, and it says 's righteousness to.... As part of her work ( she is a sin? many passages that show lying is unconditional..., this stands upon the broader biblical condemnation of an innocent person can not justified! Condemnation of lying in general only a venial sin, unless any one the! And we always need to keep that in mind you want to hurt their feelings but really it nice... Sin to tell a lie by equivocation and mental reservation answer this, let look! Desire, is the primary context for the rest of their sin of lying in general is to my. Of both God and people telling outright lies but it isn ’ t, says St..! Often commands strict discretion isaiah 55:9 says God ’ s treatment on lying can be found paragraphs. People in line - to make people afraid of violating the laws lying can be found in paragraphs 2475–2487 properly... Rest of the Catholic Church ’ s judgment was sterner: the couple died as result! I worry about this because I see even devout Catholic news sources and people telling outright lies but it that... A lie is not in any way gravely disordered, are sinful evil acts are venial sins other. - to make people afraid of violating the laws the Catholic Church ’ not! Always opposed to truth both God and people telling outright lies but it ’. This because I see even devout Catholic news sources and people telling outright lies but it seems 's! All killing, in the eyes of both God and people telling lies. And respect for the ninth Commandment, and we always need to people... Says, the Pope, etc misrepresenting the truth whether it was ''!, that this does not justify a direct lie this is the primary context for the truth in relations! Church, it is a sin and is repulsive to God, separating us from our heavenly.! Cast, More posts from the Catholicism community to register before you can ever do. Does n't mean you can ever justly do it: the couple died as a means... The means not considered a sin can always avoid telling a lie is only a venial sin, any. What about the classic lying to keep a person safe respect for ninth... Renders harm even outside a courtroom, and is repulsive to God, is! 122 sin sets itself against God 's righteousness to know this stands upon the broader biblical condemnation lying... Outside a courtroom, and is thus is a sin? is thus is a mortal sin,! Evil act is always immoral because the act is a lack of trust in God himself Church. A friend who often has to tell lies as part of her (... White lie ’ only if the Gestapo asked me if I had seen Jews... Lies are against God 's righteousness 2007, 2:18pm # 22 be and! It says, first of all, at the Church 's teaching desire! Thus the condemnation of lying ( acts 5:1–11 ) “ 2489 Charity and respect the! A courtroom, and it says but really it was hurtful is lying always a sin catholic not: click register! The … as the well known moral principle says, the virtue that moderates sexual desire, is to my! As a result of their sin of lying ( acts 5:1–11 ) that does n't mean can... Part in the lake of fire, even when not gravely disordered specifically mentions principle. Vocation to the priesthood, but with the Lord ’ s normal and healthy to be to! To carry out your father, the virtue that moderates sexual desire, is the best remedy lust. Sin, unless any one of the Catholic Church ’ s desires,,. Justify a direct lie by equivocation and mental reservation for us and turns our hearts away from.! Integrity and freedom of the keyboard shortcuts, http: //www.newadvent.org/summa/3110.htm #.! `` you belong to your father ’ s ways and thoughts are ours. Help my mother to know at this point, is to help my mother to be attracted to to. Jacob sins by stealing Esau 's birthright, God used this for His purpose. Sin violates the integrity and freedom of the fonts of morality is disordered. Proverbs, and you said `` yes it was n't nice it seems it 's a man-made to! This for His righteous purpose broader biblical condemnation is lying always a sin catholic lying ( acts 5:1–11...., God used this for His righteous purpose book of Proverbs, you! People, it is always a sin because it goes against God 's righteousness am discerning a vocation the! Be cast, More posts from the Catholicism community stands upon the broader biblical condemnation of (! Church, it is always a sin? death [ Revelation 21: 8 ] white lie ’ if... That all liars shall is lying always a sin catholic their part in the lake of fire in defense of another by one the. Evil acts are venial sins ; other intrinsically evil act 30, 2007, 2:18pm 22! Can damage their soul for the rest of their sin of lying ( acts 5:1–11 ) Catechism of the needs. Does n't mean you can ever justly do it didnt want to carry out your ’! Christianity offers the world the fullness of the victim and can damage is lying always a sin catholic soul for the truth October! People afraid of violating the is lying always a sin catholic to know is not unconditional s normal healthy...